Multiple Authorisation: The Legal Complexity of Desentralisasi in Indonesia and the Potential Contribution of IIAs in Reducing Confusion

Michael Ewing-Chow, Junianto James Losari

Full Text: PDF



DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15742/ilrev.v5n3.166

Abstract


Decentralisation system in Indonesia was introduced after the fall of the former President Soeharto with the objective of ensuring good governance and equitable development across all regions in the country. Unfortunately, the implementation of desentralisasi has been complicated. Some scholars have suggested that the model was flawed as it did not consider Indonesia’s context of less developed administrative institutions in the regions. Not only did desentralisasi cause headaches for the government, it also created confusion for foreign investors. Consequently, it affects the investment climate in the country and undermines the perception of Indonesia as an attractive place to invest in. In certain cases, desentralisasi has also led to claims by foreign investors for investor-State arbitration under Indonesia’s international investment agreements (IIAs). This paper analyses the problems of desentralisasi in Indonesia, its effects to foreign investors and suggests ways to alleviate the problems by modifying and using Indonesia’s IIAs effectively.

Keywords


decentralization; due process; international investment agreements; Indonesia

References


LEGAL DOCUMENTS

ASEAN Comprehensive Investment Agreement (adopted 26 February 2009, entered into force 29 March 2012).

Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes Between States and Nationals of Other States (adopted 18 March 1965, entered into force 14 October 1966) 17 UST 1270, TIAS 6090, 575 UNTS 159 (ICSID Convention).

Investment Chapter of the ASEAN-Australia and New Zealand Free Trade Agreement (AANZFTA).

Law No 22 of 1999 on Regional Governments.

Law No 32 of 2004 on amendment of Law No 22 of 1999 on Regional Governments.

Law No 48 of 2009 on Judicial Authority.

Law No 23 of 2014 on Regional Governments.

Regulation of the Supreme Court No 1 of 2011 on Right to Conduct Material Review.

CASES

Cemex Asia Holdings Ltd v Republic of Indonesia, ICSID Case No ARB/04/3, Parties’ Settlement Agreement (23 February 2007).

Churchill Mining v Indonesia, ICSID Case Nos ARB/12/14 and ARB/12/40, Decision on Jurisdiction (24 February 2014).

Estate of Hyacinthe Pellat (France) v United Mexican States, Decision No 34 (7 June 1929) 5 RIAA 534.

LaGrand (Germany v United States of America) (Provisional Measures) [1999] ICJ Rep 9.

Government of the Province of East Kalimantan v PT Kaltim Prima Coal, Rio Tinto Plc, BP Plc, Pacific Resources Investments Ltd, BP International Ltd, Sangatta Holdings Ltd, Kalimantan Coal Ltd, ICSID Case No ARB/07/03, Award on Jurisdiction (28 December 2009).

Metalclad Corporation v Mexico, ICSID Case No ARB(AF)/97/1, Award (30 August 2000).

Planet Mining v Indonesia, ICSID Case Nos ARB/12/14 and ARB/12/40, Decision on Jurisdiction (24 Feb 2014).

BOOKS

Aspinall, Edward and Greag Fealy (eds). Local power and politics in Indonesia: decentralization and democratization. Singapore: ISEAS, 2003.

Crawford, James. State Responsibility: The General Part. Cambridge: CUP, 2013.

Direktorat Otonomi Daerah (Bappenas). Analysis in Formulating Mid-term Policies for Revitalizing Decentralization and Regional Autonomy Processes 2010–2014 (Kajian Perumusan Arah Kebijakan Jangka Menengah Bidang Revitalisasi Proses Desentralisasi dan Otonomi Daerah Tahun 2010–2014). Jakarta: Badan Perencanaan dan Pembangunan Nasional, 2009.

Haris, Syamsuddin (ed). Decentralization and Regional Autonomy (Desentralisasi dan Otonomi Daerah). Jakarta: LIPI, 2007.

Holtzappel, Coen J G and Martin Ramstedt (eds). Decentralization and Regional Autonomy in Indonesia: Implementation and Challenges. Singapore: ISEAS, 2009.

Horowitz, Donald L. A Democratic South Africa: Constitutional Engineering in a Divided Society. California: University California Press, 1991.

Horowitz, Donald L. Constitutional Change and Democracy in Indonesia. (CUP 2013) 141.

Jansen, Marion, MS Jallab, and Maarten Smeets (eds). Connecting to Global Markets. Geneva: WTO, 2014.

UNCTAD. Best Practices in Investment for Development – How to prevent and manage investor-State disputes: Lessons from Peru. Investment Advisory Series B No 10. Geneva: United Nations, 2011.

Dirk Tomsa, ‘Review: Donald L Horowitz: Constitutional Change and Democracy in Indonesia’ (2013) 32(1) Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs 149-152.

JOURNAL ARTICLES

Djohan, Djohermansyah. ‘The Policy of Decentralization in Regional Governance in Indonesia (Kebijakan Desentralisasi Dalam Penyelenggaraan Pemerintahan Daerah di Indonesia).’ Jurnal Pamong Praja 1 (2012).

Koelble, Thomas A and Andrew Siddle. ‘Institutional complexity and unanticipated consequences: the failure of decentralization in South Africa’ Democratization 21(6) (2014): 1117-1133.

Losari, Junianto J. ‘Comprehensive or BIT by BIT: The ACIA and Indonesia’s BITs.’ Asian Journal of International Law (2015). Accessed 2 September 2015. http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?fromPage=online&aid=9537764&fileId=S2044251314000332.

Nasution, Indra K. ‘The Challenge of Decentralization in Indonesia: Symmetrical and Asymmetrical Debate.’ Int’l Journal of Social Science and Humanity 6(9) (2016): 691-697.

Nurhayaty and La Sina. ‘Juridical Analysis on Settlement of Disputes Regarding Overlapping Oil, Gas, and Coal Mining Concessions Area (Tinjauan Yuridis Penyelesaian Sengketa Tumpang Tindih Lahan Pertambangan Migas dan Batubara).’ Jurnal Beraja Inti 2(10) (2013): 3.

Pangestu, Mari, Sjamsu Rahardja, and Lili Y Ing. ‘Fifty years of Trade Policy in Indonesia: New World Trade, Old Treatments.’ Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies 51(2) (2015): 239-261.

NEWSPAPERS ARTICLES

_. ‘Indonesia in for Messy Cemex Litigation.’ Jakarta Post, 6 February 2004. Accessed 21 October 2014. http://m.thejakartapost.com/news/2004/02/06/indonesia-messy-cemex-litigation.html.

_. ‘Indonesian infrastructure promises derailed by bureaucrats.’ CNBC, 18 July 2015. Accessed 2 September 2015. http://www.cnbc.com/2015/07/18/indonesian-infrastructure-promises-derailed-by-bureaucrats.html.

_. ‘Minister Gamawan: 86 Percent of Regional Government Leaders are Corrupt (Menteri Gamawan: 86 Persen Kepala Daerah Korupsi).’ Tempo.co, 24 July 2014. Accessed 26 March 2015. http://www.tempo.co/read/news/2014/07/24/078595388/Menteri-Gamawan-86-Persen-Kepala-Daerah-Korupsi.

Akhmad, Chairul. ‘Mahfud MD: Regional Autonomy is Identic to Decentralized Corruption (Mahfud MD: Otonomi Daerah Identik Desentralisasi Korupsi).’ Republika Online, 16 June 2012. Accessed 21 October 2014. http://www.republika.co.id/berita/nasional/umum/12/06/16/m5ppoy-mahfud-md-otonomi-daerah-identik-desentralisasi-korupsi.

Cahyafitri, Raras. ‘New Law Scraps Local Govts’ Power in Mining.’ Jakarta Post, 6 October 2014. Accessed 26 March 2015. http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2014/10/06/new-law-scraps-local-govts-power-mining.html.

Djumena, Erlangga. ‘China pours Rp 645 trillion for Indonesia’s Infrastructure (Garap Infrastruktur Indonesia, Tiongkok Gelontorkan Rp 645 Triliun).’ Kompas, 25 April 2015. Accessed 2 September 2015. http://bisniskeuangan.kompas.com/read/2015/04/25/214600826/Garap.Infrastruktur.Indonesia.Tiongkok.Gelontorkan.Rp.645.Triliun.

Juwana, Hikmahanto. ‘Indonesia Should Withdraw from the ICSID.’ Jakarta Post, 2 April 2014. Accessed 21 October 2014. http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2014/04/02/indonesia-should-withdraw-icsid.html.

McCoy, Kevin. ‘Alstom Nears $700M Settlement with US.’ USA Today, 17 December 2014. Accessed 2 September 2015. http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2014/12/17/alstom-foreign-bribery-settlement/20524399/.

Pramudatama, Rabby. ‘SBY Warns of Time Bomb in RI Mining.’ Jakarta Post, 8 August 2012. Accessed 26 March 2015. http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2012/08/08/sby-warns-time-bomb-ri-mining.html.

Sihombing, Erwin. ‘In Graft Trial, Veteran Lawyer Kaligis Points Finger at Young Subordinate.’ Jakarta Globe, 31 August 2015. Accessed 2 September 2015. http://jakartaglobe.beritasatu.com/news/graft-trial-veteran-lawyer-kaligis-points-finger-young-subordinate/.

Zain, Winarno. ‘President Jokowi’s infrastructure projects: Quantity vs quality.’ Jakarta Post, 23 February 2015. Accessed 2 September 2015. http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2015/02/23/president-jokowi-s-infrastructure-projects-quantity-vs-quality.html.

MISCELLANEOUS

Ahn, Choong Y. ‘New Direction of Korea’s Foreign Direct Investment Policy In The Multi-Track FTA Era: Inducement and Aftercare Services.’ Paper presented at OECD Global Forum on International Investment (27-28 March 2008). Accessed 2 September 2015. http://www.oecd.org/investment/globalforum/40400795.pdf.

Commission of Corruption Eradication of Indonesia. ‘Memorandum of Understanding and Collective Action Plan: Annex 1 on Harmonization of Policies and Regulations (Nota Kesepakatan dan Rencana Aksi Bersama: Lampiran 1 Harmonisasi Kebijakan dan Peraturan Perundangan)’ Accessed 21 October 2014. http://acch.kpk.go.id/documents/10157/34337/Lampiran+1+-+Nota+Kesepakatan+Bersama.pdf.

Horowitz, Donald L. ‘Indonesia’s Distinctive Path to Constitutional Democracy.’ Paper presented at Conference on Comparative Constitutional Design, 16-17 October 2009.

International Law Commission. ‘Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts.’ UN GAOR 53rd Session Supp No 10, UN Doc A/56/83 (2001).

Lagarde, Christine. ‘Poised for Take-Off-Unleashing Indonesia’s Economic Potential.’ Speech delivered in Jakarta, 1 September 2015. Accessed 2 September 2015. http://www.imf.org/external/np/speeches/2015/090115.htm.

Nicolas, Françoise, Stephen Thomsen and Mi-Hyun Bang. ‘Lessons from Investment Policy Reform in Korea.’ OECD Working Papers on International Investment 2013/02 (2013).

Office of the Foreign Investment Ombudsman. ‘Overview and Mission.’ Accessed 14 September 2015. http://www.i-ombudsman.or.kr/eng/au/index.jsp?num=3.

Rondinelli, Dennis A., John R. Nellis, and G. Shabbir Cheema, ‘Decentralization in Developing Countries: A Review of Recent Experience.’ Working Paper 581. Washington DC: World Bank, 1983.




ISSN: 2356-2129