Towards Safer Seafood: What Indonesian Law Should “Say” about Mercury-Contaminated Fish

Margaretha Quina

Full Text: PDF



DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15742/ilrev.v6n2.182

Abstract


Fish is a popular culinary dish in Indonesian culture and a major economic resource on which many people depend their livelihood. However, with severe pollution in Indonesian water, including uncontrolled mercury pollution which persists in the food chain and eventually gets into humans’ body as the top predator, fish safety is particularly worrying – especially taking into account the frequency of average Indonesians’ consumption of fish. In various jurisdictions, the management tool used by lawmakers and regulators with regard to this issue is information disclosure, or known as “fish advisory warning,” to cover the failure of command and control. This paper analyses whether Indonesian laws have provided the mandate or authority to issue fish advisory warning under Fishery Law, Food Law, Environmental Protection and Management Law, and Public Information Disclosure Law. It concluded that Indonesian law implies a statutory mandate for the government to issue fish advisory warning, at least in a situation involving the threat to general life – not specifically through the Fishery Law, Food Law, or EPML, but through PIDL’s immediate information mandate.

 

 


Keywords


fish advisory warning; information disclosure; environmental justice; mercury; public health

References


Legal Documents

Indonesia. Information Commissioner Regulation No. 1 of 2010 regarding Public Information Service Standard (“IC Regulation”).

Indonesia. Peraturan Pemerintah tentang Keamanan, Kualitas dan Nutrisi Pangan (Government Regulation regarding Safety, Quality and Nutrition of Food). PP No. 28 Tahun 2004 (GR No. 28 of 2004).

Indonesia. Peraturan Pemerintah tentang Pengelolaan Kualitas Air dan Pengendalian Pencemaran Air (Government Regulation regarding Water Quality Protection and Water Pollution Control). PP No. 82 Tahun 2001, LN No. 153 Tahun 2001 (GR No. 82 of 2001, SG No. 153 of 2001).

Indonesia. The 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, the Fourth Amendment. 1945.

Indonesia. Undang-Undang tentang Administrasi Pemerintahan (Law regarding Governance Administration). UU No. 30 Tahun 2004 (Law No. 30 of 2014).

Indonesia. Undang-Undang tentang Kesehatan (Law regarding Health). UU No. 36 Tahun 2009, LN No. 144 Tahun 2009 (Law No. 36 of 2009, SG No. 36 of 2009).

Indonesia. Undang-Undang tentang Keterbukaan Informasi Publik (Law regarding Public Information Disclosure). UU No. 14 Tahun 2008, LN No. 4846 Tahun 2008 (Law No. 14 of 2008, SG No. 4846 of 2008).

Indonesia. Undang-Undang tentang Pangan (Law regarding Food). UU No. 18 Tahun 2012, LN No. 227 Tahun 2012 (Law no. 18 of 2012, SG No. 227 of 2012).

Indonesia. Undang-Undang tentang Perikanan (Law regarding Fishery). UU No. 31 Tahun 2004, LN No. 154 Tahun 2009 (Law No. 31 of 2004, SG No. 154 of 2009).

Indonesia. Undang-Undang tentang Perlindungan dan Pengelolaan Lingkungan Hidup (Environmental Protection and Management Law). UU No. 32 Tahun 2009, LN No. 140 Tahun 2009 (Law No. 32 of 2009, SG No. 140 of 2009).

Indonesia. Undang-Undang tentang Perlindungan Konsumen (Law regarding Consumer Protection). UU No. 8 Tahun 1999, LN No. 42 Tahun 1999 (Law No. 8 of 1999, SG No. 42 of 1999).

Ministry of Health Regulation No. 2 of 2013 regarding Food Poisoning Outbreak.

Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Fishery Regulation No. PER.15/MEN/2010 regarding the Organization and Governance of Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Fishery.

Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Fishery. MMAF Regulation No. PER.19-MEN-2010 regarding Control of Quality Assurance System and Fishery Products Safety (“MMAF Regulation”).

Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Fishery. Regulation of Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Fishery No. PER,19/MEN/2010 regarding Control of Fishery Products Quality Assurance and Safety System.

Books

Chiang, Audrey. A Seafood Consumption Survey of the Laotian Community in West Contra Costa County. Report of the Asian Pacific Environmental Network (APEN). California, Asian Pacific Environmental Network: 1998.

Constitutional Court, the Republic of Indonesia. Comprehensive Text of Book VIII of Indonesia 1945 Constitution. 2010.

Dewi, Kania and Ismawati, Yuyun. Inventory of Mercury Releases in Indonesia. Denpasar: Balifokus, 2012.

EPA Office of Water. Guidance for Assessing Chemical Contaminant Data for Use in Fish Advisories, Volume IV: Risk Communication 10. 1995.

NEJAC. Fish Consumption and Environmental Justice. Report Developed from the National Environmental Justice Advisory Council Meeting, December 3-6, 2001. Seattle: National Environmental Justice Advisory Council, 2001.

Glassburner, Bruce. The Economy of Indonesia: Selected Reading. Sheffield: Equinox Publishing, 2007.

Hadden, Susan G. A Citizen’s Right to Know: Risk Communication and Public Policy. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1989.

ICEL. Strengthening the Right of Information for People and the Environment (STRIPE) Final Report: Case Study from Indonesia. Jakarta: ICEL, 2013.

Indonesian Center for Environmental Law. Study on Mercury Regulation in Indonesia. Jakarta: ICEL, 2012.

Ismawati, Yuyun. Policy Brief: ASGM in Indonesia. Denpasar: BaliFokus, 2010.

NEJAC, Fish Consumption and Environmental Justice. New Jersey: 2002.

Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards & Office of Research and Development, US EPA. Mercury Study Report to Congress, Volume 1: Executive Summary. EPA-452/R-97-003. 1997.

Office of Water, EPA. “Guidance for Assessing Chemical Contaminant Data for Use in Fish Advisories.” Volume IV: Risk Communication 10.

Pusat Kebijakan Regional dan Bilateral Kementerian Keuangan RI dan Program Studi Kajian Wilayah Eropa Program Pascasarjana Universitas Indonesia. Kajian Kerja Sama Bilateral Indonesia - Uni Eropa: Bidang Ekonomi dan Keuangan [Study on Bilateral Partnership between Indonesia – European Union: Economic and Financial Area]. Jakarta, Pusat Kebijakan Regional dan Bilateral Program Studi Kajian Wilayah Eropa Program Pascasarjana Universitas Indonesia, 2012.

Rasband, James; Salzman, James; and Squillace, Mark. Natural Resources Law and Policy. 2nd ed. St. Paul, MN: Foundation Press, 2009.

Rechtschaffen, Clifford, Eileen Gaune, and Catherine O’Neill. Environmental Justice: Law, Policy and Regulation. 2nd Edition. Durham, NC: Carolina Academic Press, 2009.

UNEP. Global Mercury Assessment 2013: Sources, Emissions, Releases and Environmental Transport. Geneva: UNEP Chemicals Branch, 2013.

Articles

Castilhos, Zuleica C., et. al. “Mercury Contamination in Fish from Gold Mining Areas in Indonesia and Human Health Risk Assessment,” Science of the Total Environment 368, issue 1 (September, 2006): 320-325.

Esty, Daniel C. “Environmental Protection in the Information Age.” NYU Law Review 79, (2004): 117-209.

O’Neill, Catherine. “No Mud Pies: Risk Avoidance as Risk Regulations.” Vermont Law Review 31 (2006-7): 273-326.

O’Neill, Catherine. “Risk Avoidance, Cultural Discrimination and Environmental Justice for Indigenous People.” Ecology Law Quarterly 30, (2003).

Renshaw, Katherine. “Sounding Alarm: Does Informational Regulation Help or Hinder Environmentalism.” NYU Environmental Law Journal 14 (2005-6).

Plunkett, David and Caroline Smith De Waal. “Who is Responsible for the Safety of Food in a Global Market? Government Certification v. Importer Accountability as Models for Assuring the Safety of Internationally Traded Foods.” Food and Drug Law Journal 63 (2008): 657-664.

Websites

EPA. “EPA Technical Memorandum: Origin of 1 Meal/week.” http://water.epa.gov/scitech/swguidance/fishshellfish/outreach/upload/2004_07_21_fish_advice_1-meal-per-week.pdf. Accessed on 30 March 2015.

EPA. “Risk Assessment: Basic Information.” http://www.epa.gov/risk_assessment/basicinformation.htm#a1. Accessed on 13 March 2015.

Southerland, Elizabeth. “Proceedings of the National Forum on Contaminants in Fish, May 6 and 9, 2001 1-10 (2001).”

http://www.epa.gov/ost/fish/forum/fishforum.pdf. Accessed on 26 March 2015.

Transparency International. “Corruption Perception Index.

https://www.transparency.org/cpi2014/results. Accessed on 25 March, 2015.

U.S. Dept. of Health and Human Service. & U.S. EPA. “What You Need to Know About Mercury in Fish and Shellfish.” http://www.epa.gov/waterscience/fishadvice/advisory.pdf. Accessed on 24 March 2015.

United Nations Commodity Trade Statistic. “Mercury Trade Database.” http://comtrade.un.org. Accessed in March 2015.

World Bank. Worldwide Governance Indicators. http://info.worldbank.org/governance/wgi/index.aspx#reports. Accessed on 29 March 2015.

ZOI Environment Network. “Mercury Trade Map 2011.” http://www.zoinet.org/web/sites/default/files/publications/MercuryTradeMap2011.pdf. Accessed on March 25, 2015.

Daniel C. Esty, Environmental Protection in the Information Age, 79 N.Y.U. L. REV. 115, 117 (2004).

Elizabeth Southerland, Proceedings of the National Forum on Contaminants in Fish, May 6 and 9, 2001 1-10 (2001), available at http://www.epa.gov/ost/fish/forum/fishforum.pdf.

EPA Office of Water, Guidance for Assessing Chemical Contaminant Data for Use in Fish Fish Advisories, Volume IV: Risk Communication 10 (1995).

EPA, EPA Technical Memorandum: Origin of 1 Meal/week, available at http://water.epa.gov/scitech/swguidance/fishshellfish/outreach/upload/2004_07_21_fish_advice_1-meal-per-week.pdf

EPA, RISK ASSESSMENT: BASIC INFORMATION, available at http://www.epa.gov/risk_assessment/basicinformation.htm#a1

Government Regulation no. 28 of 2004 regarding Safety, Quality and Nutrition of Food; Ministry of Health Regulation no. 2 of 2013 regarding Food Poisoning Outbreak.

Government Regulation no. 82 of 2001 regarding Water Pollution Control (“WPC Regulation”)

ICEL, Strengthening the Right of Information for People and the Environment (STRIPE) Final Report: Case Study from Indonesia (2013), at 55-6.

Indonesia ranked 107th in the Transparency International’s Corruption Perception Index 2014, see Transparency International, CPI, available at https://www.transparency.org/cpi2014/results.

Indonesia, Constitution of Republic of Indonesia, Art. 28H; see also Consitutional Court, Republic of Indonesia, COMPREHENSIVE TEXT OF BOOK VIII OF INDONESIA CONSTITUTION 1945 (2010).

Indonesia, Law no. 14 of 2008 regarding Public Information Disclosure (“PIDA”); see also Information Commissioner Regulation no. 1 of 2010 regarding Public Information Service Standard.

Indonesia, Law no. 18 of 2012 regarding Food.

Indonesia, Law no. 31 of 2004 regarding Fishery.

Indonesia, Law no. 32 of 2009 regarding Environmental Protection and Management Act.

Indonesia, Law no. 36 of 2009 regarding Health.

Indonesian Center for Environmental Law (2012) STUDY ON MERCURY REGULATION IN INDONESIA.

Indonesian National Standards (Standar Nasional Indonesia, hereinafter referred to as “SNI”) for the Maximum Level of Heavy Metal Contamination in Food, SNI 7387:2009 (2009).

James Rasband, James Salzman, and Mark Squillace, NATURAL RESOURCES LAW AND POLICY (Foundation Press, 2d ed., 2009).

Katherine Renshaw (2006) Sounding Alarm: Does Informational Regulation Help or Hinder Environmentalism, 14 N.Y.U. ENVTL. L.J. 654 2005-6.

Marine Affairs and Fishery Ministry Regulation No. PER.15/MEN/2010 regarding Organization and Governance of Marine Affairs and Fishery Ministry.

Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Fishery Regulation no. No. PER.19-MEN-2010 regarding Control of Quality Assurance System and Fishery Products Safety.

NATIONAL RISK COMMUNICATION CONFERENCE, Proceedings Document 1-11 (2001), cited in NEJAC.

NEJAC (2002) FISH CONSUMPTION AND ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE.

NEJAC (2002) Fish Consumption and Environmental Justice: A Report Developed from the National Environmental Justice Advisory Council Meeting of December 3-6, 2001.

Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards & Office of Research and Development, US EPA, MERCURY STUDY REPORT TO CONGRESS, VOLUME 1: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY, EPA-452/R-97-003 (1997).

Office of Water, EPA, GUIDANCE FOR ASSESSING CHEMICAL CONTAMINANT DATA FOR USE IN FISH ADVISORIES, VOLUME IV: RISK COMMUNICATION 10 (1995)

Plunkett and de Waal (2008) ASSURING THE SAFETY OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE FOODS Indonesia, Law no. 8 of 1999 regarding Consumer Protection.

Presidential Regulation no. 16 of 2015 regarding Environmental and Forestry Ministry

Pusat Kebijakan Regional dan Bilateral Kementerian Keuangan RI dan Program Studi Kajian Wilayah Eropa Program Pascasarjana Universitas Indonesia, KAJIAN KERJA SAMA BILATERAL INDONESIA - UNI EROPA: BIDANG EKONOMI DAN KEUANGAN, Jakarta: 2012.

Regulation of Maritime Affairs and Fishery Ministry No. PER,19/MEN/2010 regarding Control of Fishery Products Quality Assurance and Safety System.

SNI for the Maximum Level of Heavy Metal Contamination in Food, supra note 66.

Susan G. Hadden, A CITIZEN’S RIGHT TO KNOW: RISK COMMUNICATION AND PUBLIC POLICY 157 (1989).

U.S. Dept. of Health and Human Servs. & U.S. EPA, WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT MERCURY IN FISH AND SHELLFISH (2004) [hereinafter FDA/EPA Advisory], available at http://www.epa.gov/waterscience/fishadvice/advisory.pdf.

UNEP (2013) GLOBAL MERCURY ASSESSMENT: SOURCES, EMISSIONS, RELEASES AND ENVIRONMENTAL TRANSPORT

United Nations Commodity Trade Statistic, MERCURY TRADE DATABASE, available at http://comtrade.un.org

World Bank, Worldwide Governance Indicators, available at http://info.worldbank.org/governance/wgi/index.aspx#reports.

Yuyun Ismawati, Policy Brief: ASGM in Indonesia, Denpasar: BaliFokus, 2010

ZOI Environment Network, MERCURY TRADE MAP 2011, available at http://www.zoinet.org/web/sites/default/files/publications/MercuryTradeMap2011.pdf.

Zuleica Carmen Castilhos, et.al. (2006) Mercury Contamnination in Fish from Gold Mining Areas in Indonesia and Human Health Risk Assessment.




ISSN: 2356-2129