Unaccompanied & Denied: Regional Legal Framework for Unaccompanied Minors Asylum Seekers (UMAS)

Rohaida Nordin, Jennifer Whelan, Saidatul Nadia Abd Aziz, Meerah Deiwi Rajagopal, Izza Munirah Mansor, Marianne Touma, Max Ralton

Full Text: PDF



DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15742/ilrev.v5n3.186

Abstract


Unaccompanied minor asylum seekers are vulnerable and thus, provided special international law protections. However, in reality, they are being mistreated as illegal immigrants and on the
receiving end of ethnic violence, discrimination, restrictions in enjoyment of their rights duly recognised by international human rights law. This article identifies legislative, policy and support
mechanisms which encompass the minimum UMAS guardianship standards at international law and which are evidence-based from best practice models for the provision of guardians for UMAS
internationally. It presents situation of UMAS in relation to human rights violations with emphasis on the legal framework and practices in Australia and five ASEAN State Members. This article also highlights the various stands taken by various countries providing better legal framework and practices regarding the terms for protection and enforcement of human rights for UMAS. Finally, this article provides recommendations for Australia and ASEAN Member States to adopt in order to realise the international human rights of UMAS with respect to guardianship.

Keywords


Human rights; asylum seekers; unaccompanied minor asylum seekers; Australia; ASEAN

References


Australian Immigration (Guardianship of Children) Act 1946 (Cth)

Australian Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Australian Human Rights Commission, ‘Submission to the Joint Select Committee on Australia’s Immigration Detention Network’ (August 2011), available at

Australian Red Cross, ‘Asylum Seeker Assistance Scheme’, available at

Australian Human Rights Commission, ‘2011 Immigration detention at Villawood: Summary of observations from visit to immigration detention facilities at Villawood’ (2011), page 25

Australian Human Rights Commission, ‘Human rights issues raised by the transfer of asylum seekers to third countries’ (November 2012), page 17

Antje Missbach and Frieda Sinanu, ‘“The Scum of the Earth”? Foreign People Smugglers and Their Local Counterparts in Indonesia’ (2011) 30(4) Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs 57, page 67

Chris Bowen MP, Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, ‘Moving asylum seeker children into the community’ (1 March 2011), available at ;

Child Rights Coalition Malaysia, ‘Report for the Universal Periodic Review’ (2013), p.8, available at

Child Rights Coalition Malaysia, ‘Report for the Universal Periodic Review’ (2013), p.8, available at

Carla Buil, ‘A profile of Afghan unaccompanied minors in the Netherlands’ (2011), p.37, available at

Committee on the Rights of the Child, “2012 Day of General Discussion: the Rights of All Children in the Context of International Migration”, p.3.

Carla Buil, ‘A rights-based approach to Afghan unaccompanied minors in the Netherlands’ (2012), page 2, available at

Committee on the Rights of the Child, Consideration of Reports Submitted by State Parties under Article 44 of the Convention, Concluding observations: The Philippines, 52nd session, UN Doc CRC/C/PHL/CO/3-4 (22 October 2009), paragraphs 67 and 68.

Danish Immigration Service, ‘Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh and Thailand: Fact finding mission Bangladesh and Thailand’ (May 2011), page 46, available at

Department of Immigration and Citizenship, ‘Annual Report 2011-2012: Offshore asylum seeker management’ (2012), available at

Department of Immigration and Citizenship, ‘Response to the 2011 Australian Human Rights Commission Statement on Immigration Detention in Villawood’, page 2, available at

Department of Immigration and Citizenship, ‘Australian Immigration Fact Sheet 69. Caring for Unaccompanied Minors’, available at

Directive from the Director General of Immigration No. F-IL.01.10-1297 on Procedures Regarding Aliens Expressing Their Desire to Seek Asylum or Refugee Status (Indonesia), No. F-IL.01.10-1297, (30 September 2002), available at

Department of Justice, Department Order No. 94/1998: Establishing a Procedure for Processing Applications for the Grant of Refugee Status (4 March 1998), available at

Department of Justice, Department Order No. 94/1998: Establishing a Procedure for Processing Applications for the Grant of Refugee Status (4 March 1998), section 14, available at

Defence for Children International-ECPAT the Netherlands, ‘Closing a Protection Gap’ (December 2010), p.34, available at

Dutch Civil Code, Book 1: Law of Persons and Family Law, article 245.

European Network of Guardianship Institutions (ENGI), ‘Towards a European Network of Guardianship Institutions’ (February 2010), page 47, available at (30 March 2013).

European Migration Network, ‘Policies on Reception, Return and Integration arrangements for, and numbers of, Unaccompanied Minors- an EU comparative study’ (2009); Anna Lundberg and Lisa Dahlquist, ‘Unaccompanied Children Seeking Asylum in Sweden: Living Conditions from a Child-Centred Perspective’, 31(2) Refugee Survey Quarterly 54.

European Network of Guardianship Institutions (ENGI), Towards a European Network of Guardianship Institutions (February 2010), page 48, available at

General Comment No. 6 (2005) “Treatment of Unaccompanied and Separated Children Outside Their Country of Origin”

Hungarian Act IV of 1952 on Marriage, Family and Guardianship

Hungarian XXXI Act on child protection and public guardianship administration (1997) and the 149/1997 (IX. 10) Government Decree on the guardianship authority, and on child protection and guardianship proceedings, cited by International Organisation for Migration (IOM), ‘Overview of guardianship systems for unaccompanied minor asylum-seekers in Central Europe- Synthesis report’ (2012), p.39.

Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission, ‘A last resort? National Inquiry into Children in Immigration Detention’ (2004), pages 18-19, available at

Human Rights Watch, ‘Ad Hoc and Inadequate: Thailand’s Treatment of Refugees and Asylum Seekers’ (2011), available at

Indonesian Immigration Law UU6 2011, article 83(1).

International Detention Coalition, ‘There are Alternatives: A handbook for preventing unnecessary detention’ (2011), p.25, available at

Immigration and Naturalisation Service (IND), Staff Directorate for Implementation and Policy (SUB), Section Information and Analysis Centre (INDIAC), Dutch National Contact Point for the European Migration Network (EMN), ‘EMN-study: Unaccompanied minors in the Netherlands’ (February 2010), p.6, available at

International Organisation for Migration (IOM), ‘Overview of guardianship systems for unaccompanied minor asylum-seekers in Central Europe- Synthesis report’ (2012), p.14, available at See for example, Child Protection Act (1997) on child protection and guardianship administration.

JRS Asia Pacific, ‘The Search: Protection Space in Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, Cambodia and the Philippines’ (2012), available at pages 17-19

Jera Beah H. Lego, ‘Frameworks for the Protection of Refugees and Asylum-Seekers in Malaysia and Thailand: Implications and Prospects’ (2012), p.2, available at

Jera Beah H. Lego, ‘Protecting and Assisting Refugees and Asylum-Seekers in Malaysia: The Role of the UNHCR, Informal Mechanisms, and the “Humanitarian Exception”’ (2012) 17 Journal of Political Sociology 75, p.88 citing Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (Suhakam), ‘Annual Report 2009’, p.35.

Jera Beah H. Lego, ‘Protecting and Assisting Refugees and Asylum-Seekers in Malaysia: The Role of the UNHCR, Informal Mechanisms, and the “Humanitarian Exception”’ (2012) 17 Journal of Political Sociology 75, p.89.

Life Without Barriers, ‘Refugees and Asylum Seekers’, available at

LIRS and Migration and Refugee Services United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, ‘A Shady Tree: Hope for Vulnerable Refugees in Malaysia and Thailand’ (2006), page 11, available at

Malaysian Guardianship of Infants Act 1961

Malaysian Immigration Act 1959/1963

Mary Crock and Mary Anne Kenny, ‘Rethinking the Guardianship of Refugee Children after the Malaysian Solution’, 34 Sydney Law Review 437, page 451.

Migration Legislation Amendment (Regional Processing and Other Measures) Bill 2012 (Cth).

Nidos, ‘Annual Report’ (2007), available at

Philippine Immigration Act No. 613 of 1940 (as amended), section 47(B); Department of Justice, Department Order No. 94/1998: Establishing a Procedure for Processing Applications for the Grant of Refugee Status (4 March 1998), available at

Parliament of Australia, ‘Budget Review 2012-13: National Children’s Commissioner’ (May 2012), available at

Thai Civil Law, available at

The Bali Process on People Smuggling, Trafficking in Persons and Related Transnational Crime, ‘Mapping and Analyzing the Protection Situation of Unaccompanied and Separated children in South East Asia’ Project (2012), available at

UNHCR, ‘Guidelines on Policies and Procedures in Dealing with Unaccompanied Children Seeking Asylum’ (February 1997), article 5.7.

UNHCR, ‘2013 UNHCR regional operations profile - South-East Asia’ (2013), available at




ISSN: 2356-2129